“Jesus saith unto her, Woman, what have I to do with thee? mine hour is not yet come.”
King James Version (KJV)
S. Ellis's comment on 2021-02-14 17:12:26:
I believe that Mary, being a devout believer, knew Isaiah 25 and saw the implications of that prophecy in the lack of wine at the wedding in Cana. Notice she did not ask Jesus to do anything, just called his attention to the symbolism. She did not demand He do something. I believe his response was not rude but confirmation to her of who he was, using the term Woman. If one can see it as an authoritative statement not an insult. When he says "Mine hour is not yet come", it appears He is not talking about His ministry, but His death, again confirming who He is. This seemed to prompt Mary into action, recognizing the manifestation of the scripture through his words. He satisfied the need as it fits the prophecy of Isaiah 25, a very recognizable prophecy of who He was. He would again refer to her as Woman at the Cross. Again, authoritative, not rude.
Chris's comment on 2020-10-21 18:10:04:
Since we're not given a whole lot of details to work on, that phrase, "mine hour is not yet come" could be Jesus' declaration that the correct time for the revelation of His Person, Ministry & Purpose in man's redemption had not yet arrived. His Mother would have known that the Divine Seed that was implanted in her about 31 years ago, was now standing in the midst of this marriage ceremony & well able to perform the works of God. And in this hour of need at the ceremony, what a great time it would be to show the people Who Jesus really is as well as help the marriage hosts out. "Killing two birds with one stone" is often a human inclination done because of having a narrow perspective. But Jesus retorted, that the appointed time had not come, but for the sake of his Mother's request (& maybe, her pleas), Jesus consented to her wish.
I see this event as both Jesus' acknowledgement of his familial position as a son before his Mother as well as being directed by His Heavenly Father for the planned revelation of His Son to Israel. All that the Father has purposed for His Son (& for each one of us) fits perfectly into His timeline & order, so even though "His hour (of revelation) had not yet come", this 'first' miracle at this particular time would not necessarily throw the Divine timing out, rather, brought it forward a notch with the other events that showed the divinity of Jesus naturally following on according to that Plan.
Timing is Everything's comment on 2020-10-21 17:45:23:
This instance was Jesus's first miracle performed. He wasn't rebuking Mary. He was reminding that the appointed time to begin doing miracles had not yet arrived.
They both knew he could; the time to begin had not bean given by The Father yet.
In my experience; don't run ahead of the Lord. I did, Once. I was promptly corrected. (The Holy Spirit was speaking to my spirit)..."are you ready to do it My Way?"
(Concerning street evangelism.)
He didn't reprove me. Just asked a question. I learned to LOVE hearing that Shepherd's voice that day!!!
Mishael
curtiss cordy's comment on 2020-10-21 10:44:33:
what did jesus mean when he told mary my hour is not yet come.
Jose Cruz's comment on 2015-08-01 21:06:54:
The actions of yeshua here regarding the answer to Mary was simply honoring the ten commandments. He first honored His mother. If we look at the ten comandmants and this verse, we can see how Yeshua is giving us an example as children to our parents. It also shows how a parent respects the space of their children. We can see this verse in difrent ways but I believe the most important way to see this is like this: Yeshua is God, so... how come He is under a woman's authority? The simple answer is in the next chapters were he says that he didn't come to change the law's but to perfect them. Everything that is written by yeshua was simply to show us how to live.. being the Lord of Host he gave everything to humble himself to serve us.
Becky's comment on 2014-08-15 11:20:15:
Mary mentioned it in passing.She didn 't ask for him to fix it. Jesus turned to her and made the point that his time had not yet come as an announcement that it was about to. Mary recognized her error, so she put it in God 's hands, she even gave him her servants because by her faith she realized all she had to do was put everything in God 's hands to do what he thought was best in his own time.
earl's comment on 2014-03-30 11:26:13:
It seems to me that although both she and Jesus knew he was a miracle worker, they both knew this instance was a minor situation and need not have been brought to him. She knew he could fix it. and as did he too. But do we? So often we deem our own problems beneath the care of Jesus, as if our situation were not worthy of his concern. His Mother knew him well enough to know, hem can fix anything. No task is too trivial no job too small, no problem to simple that we make a decision to abort our praying to God about it. He actually does care about the trivialities and the mundane occurrences of our lives.Are we to Judge what he can and cannot handle? Let him be the judge of it.
mart's comment on 2013-09-29 22:16:41:
By Jesus addressing His Blessed Mother as Woman was to confirm and reaffirm to the whole World the designation of Virgin Mary as the New Eve therefore the word "Woman". It is "The Woman" who will step-on and crush the head of the serpent (the devil).
Ann Ryan's comment on 2013-09-28 19:48:02:
Jesus is being unnecessarily rude to his mother. Being special gives you less, not more, excuse for behaving badly
G.Matthews's comment on 2012-05-20 21:01:12:
The Lord was not disrespectful but He was definitely rebuking her knowing her name will be infamously exalted as the Queen of Heaven, co-redeemer and Intercessor. Today she is not the mother of Christ but the daughter of Christ. Unless she had repented and was born of God she would not have gone to Heaven when she died.
wes rosa's comment on 2011-04-20 07:00:48:
hes telling her like silly mom not this kind of wine am i talkin about all the time thats to come later very respectful in a son to mom way cuz she is still his mom